Post-Exertional Malaise and Hypermobility

By Jennifer Richards LMT

When doing too much costs more than we realize

A guide for people living with hypermobility, Ehlers-Danlos syndromes, and hypermobility spectrum disorders—and the bodyworkers who care for them.

Introduction

Imagine having a wonderful day: running errands, cleaning, meeting friends, or finishing a project. You feel accomplished. Then, a day or two later, you develop profound exhaustion, widespread pain, brain fog, and difficulty managing ordinary tasks. This may be post-exertional malaise (PEM), rather than ordinary muscle soreness.

PEM is not an inevitable or defining feature of hypermobility. When it occurs, it deserves evaluation rather than being automatically attributed to joint laxity.

1. What is post-exertional malaise?

PEM is a worsening of symptoms after physical, cognitive, emotional, or social exertion that exceeds an individual’s current capacity. It may begin hours later or be delayed by 12–48 hours, involve multiple body systems, and last days or longer.

PEM is a hallmark of myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) and also occurs in some people with Long COVID. Not all exercise intolerance is PEM: pain, orthostatic intolerance, deconditioning, and other conditions can look similar. [1, 2]

2. Why might it occur with hypermobility?

Joint instability and muscular effort: Symptomatic hypermobility may increase muscular stabilization demands, but that alone does not establish the cause of delayed, multisystem PEM.

Dysautonomia and POTS: Rapid heart rate, dizziness, heat intolerance, and difficulty remaining upright can reduce activity tolerance. POTS and PEM may coexist, but they are not the same phenomenon.

Pain and sleep: Chronic pain and disrupted sleep can worsen fatigue and recovery. Fatigue alone, however, should not be mistaken for PEM. [3]

Coexisting ME/CFS or Long COVID: Repeated delayed crashes in a person with hEDS/HSD warrant assessment for these and other medical conditions.

3. What happens in the body?

The mechanisms of PEM remain under investigation. Research explores changes in energy metabolism, immune signaling, autonomic regulation, circulation, and responses to exertion. No single explanation has been proven for every person. PEM should not be dismissed as poor motivation or merely being out of shape. [2, 4]

4. How can crashes be minimized?

Pace activity within the current “energy envelope,” considering mental, social, and physical demands. Track symptoms for 24–72 hours after activity to identify delayed patterns. Schedule rest before severe exhaustion rather than waiting until a crash begins.

Adapt movement and rehabilitation individually. Strengthening can be valuable for joint stability, but when PEM is present, fixed exercise increases that provoke symptom worsening are inappropriate. No approach guarantees prevention of all crashes. [1, 5]

5. Which healthcare professionals can help?

A primary care clinician can assess symptoms, consider other causes (such as anemia, thyroid disorders, sleep problems, and nutritional deficiencies), and coordinate referrals. An ME/CFS-informed clinician can evaluate characteristic PEM. A cardiologist or autonomic specialist may assess POTS; a neurologist or rheumatologist may help when indicated.

Physical therapists familiar with both hypermobility and PEM can tailor stabilization work to symptom limits. Occupational therapists can support energy conservation, and sleep specialists can investigate treatable sleep disorders. There is no single laboratory test that confirms PEM.

New chest pain, significant breathlessness, fainting, or new neurological deficits need prompt medical assessment rather than being presumed to be PEM.

6. What should massage therapists and bodyworkers consider?

A massage appointment includes more than time on the table. Travel, dressing, changing positions, sensory stimulation, and returning home all add to the client’s total activity burden. Even gentle treatment may be too much for some people.

Before treatment, ask: Do symptoms worsen after physical or mental activity? Is the decline delayed? How long does recovery take? Have previous massages caused delayed crashes? What other exertion has occurred today? Ask about ME/CFS, Long COVID, POTS, and relevant diagnoses without attempting to diagnose them.

During treatment, consider shorter sessions, conservative pressure, supportive positioning, temperature and sensory accommodations, and slow transitions from the table. Avoid aggressive stretching or end-range joint loading with unstable joints. Do not interpret exhaustion as proof of an effective treatment.

After treatment, ask about delayed changes at 24–48 hours (and later if relevant). Document duration, techniques, positioning, symptom response, and recovery time. If a crash follows, reconsider the total treatment burden, not just the pressure, and refer for medical evaluation as appropriate.

These are precautionary practice considerations, not validated massage protocols for PEM. Direct evidence that any particular massage technique prevents PEM is lacking.

7. Can massage help?

Massage may provide comfort, temporary pain relief, relaxation, or subjective well-being for some clients. It has not been established as a treatment for PEM itself, and there is insufficient evidence that it prevents crashes. For some people, postponing treatment may be the safest choice.

8. Why “push through it” can be harmful

Progressive strengthening may be appropriate for symptomatic hypermobility without PEM. In contrast, for people with ME/CFS and PEM, a fixed exercise progression that disregards symptoms can worsen illness. NICE advises against fixed-increment graded exercise therapy as a treatment for ME/CFS. This is not advice for all hypermobile people to avoid movement; it is a reason to distinguish conditions carefully. [5]

9. A message to people living with hypermobility

Learning your limits is not giving up. It is using information about your body to make safer decisions. The goal is not to stop living; it is to participate in life without repeatedly paying for it with days of illness.

Final thought for bodyworkers

A session should not be judged only by how relaxed a client feels immediately afterward. For someone vulnerable to PEM, what happens in the next several days matters just as much. The goal is not simply to help someone feel better on the table—it is to avoid making life harder after they leave it.

Resources and references

[1] CDC. Strategies to Prevent Worsening of Symptoms (ME/CFS). https://www.cdc.gov/me-cfs/hcp/clinical-care/treating-the-most-disruptive-symptoms-first-and-preventing-worsening-of-symptoms.html

[2] CDC. Clinical Overview of ME/CFS. https://www.cdc.gov/me-cfs/hcp/clinical-overview/

[3] The Ehlers-Danlos Society. Fatigue in EDS and HSD. https://www.ehlers-danlos.com/fatigue/

[4] CDC. Managing Post-Exertional Malaise in ME/CFS (handout). https://www.cdc.gov/me-cfs/pdfs/toolkit/managing-pem_508.pdf

[5] NICE. Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (or Encephalopathy)/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: Diagnosis and Management, NG206 (2021). https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng206/chapter/recommendations

Editorial note: Fatigue is well recognized in hEDS/HSD, but the prevalence and mechanisms of true PEM specifically in hypermobility populations are not yet adequately established. This article is educational and does not replace medical assessment or professional scope-of-practice requirements.

Leave a Comment